Five Flights Finds Complexity in Simplicity

The Cast of Don't Step on the Cracks
Photo by Bert Berat

To say that Five Flights Theater Company’s new production of Don’t Step on the Cracks is “simply wonderful” would be to do the company a grave disservice. Though the play is mostly inspired by children’s books and poems, there is nothing simplistic about it.

Created entirely by the members of the newly formed Five Flights Theater Company, Don’t Step on the Cracks is about growing up and looking back. The very talented cast, made up entirely of Marymount students and alumni, takes us through a series of skits examining the moment when you realize it’s time to grow up.

From the very start, the introduction to the show—expertly written and choreographed by Eryck Tait—mixes the worlds of youth and adulthood together, weaving original lines from the play with familiar verses from Shel Silverstein poems to accentuate the shift into maturity. It sets up the events to come as we watch our own childhoods mature in the characters and themes presented during the show.

The characters and situations are familiar—bits of our childhood shown back to us under the lens of experience. Will Lacker exposes the “truth” behind Puff the Magic Dragon’s relationship with Jackie Paper. Sara Lukasiewicz navigates the everyday life of Amelia Bedelia, who takes things too literally. Jake Bartush, Eryck Tait, and Adam Delia take us on a journey in a flying shoe with Ickle Me, Pickle Me and Tickle Me, too. Other sketches give examples of moments in the lives of twenty-somethings faced with real grown-up problems.

At its core, Don’t Step on the Cracks analyzes loss. Loss of innocence, but also loss of friends, family, pets, even childhood idols. In the incredibly poignant “Goodnight, Moon” (written and performed by Jake Bartush) a high school student comes to terms with the suicide of a classmate, and the realization that “he was simply the first one to succeed.”

This production is actually a re-mounting of their premiere production, which played at Center Stage on West 21st Street last July. I was lucky enough to catch both productions, and am happy to say that this show has only gotten stronger. Most noticeably stronger are Sara Lukasiewicz’s “Amelia” monologues, written and directed by Five Flights Stage Manager Alli Taylor. Ms. Lukasiewicz’s sense of innocence in these pieces brings adult issues to light through the lens of youth in a refreshing opposition to the rest of the show.

It is no secret that I have worked with the majority of the people in this company in the past and am a vocal fan of their work. I may seem biased in this instance. Still, the reception to the performance I was at and the sold out three-performance run at Center Stage speaks for itself.

I think a lot of the success can be credited to the unique nature of the company itself. Formed in a five-flight walk-up (hence the name) they started as a bunch of theatre artists with an idea for a show. The sketches were written, some were handed off to directors, all were assigned to actors, rehearsed and put back together again to create the show. “It’s the only form of communism I’ve seen that works,” company member Claire McGinley commented.

For me, the heart of the show and of the company can be summed up in one line from a piece by Ms. McGinley. In the final scene of the play, Eryck Tait turns to Laurel Casillo and says, “You know we can’t live forever.” She responds: “But I’ve always wanted to try.” This is a company that—if I may make a prediction—will be around for a long time and will produce important pieces of new theatre. I hate to gush, but I mean it when I say I highly anticipate great new works to come out of Five Flights in the future.

Still, I think that Don’t Step on the Cracks may just turn out to be Five Flights’ staple. Its resonance hits a place that we all need to go to every now and then, and I won’t be surprised to see this show pop up in new productions, just when we need it most. You’ll be certain to find me there every time.


Don't Step on the Cracks is no longer running.